illustration of a tech worker sitting at a desk with a laptop

Marketing Baby

The Shelfware Dilemma (Edition 2023)


In today’s fast-paced digital environment, where every penny in a company’s budget is scrutinized for its return on investment, there lurks an often-overlooked drain on resources: shelfware. Imagine a scenario where up to 37% of your software spending vanishes into the ether, providing zero value in return. For many, this isn’t just a hypothetical – it’s a stark reality.

Shelfware, broadly defined, refers to software that has been purchased but remains unused or grossly underutilized.

While this phenomenon impacts businesses across the board, it carries particular significance for marketers. In a world driven by data and tight budgets, marketers need every tool at their disposal to be firing on all cylinders. Every dollar locked into unused software is a dollar not spent on high-impact campaigns, innovative strategies, or crucial audience insights.

But beyond the financial implications, there’s another dimension to the shelfware conundrum. In an age where data-driven decision-making is paramount, underutilized tools can fragment data sources, muddying the waters of analysis and hampering accurate targeting and segmentation. For marketers, this isn’t just about wasted money; it’s about missed opportunities and skewed insights.

In this article, we’ll delve deep into the world of shelfware, exploring its origins, its implications, and most importantly, actionable strategies to ensure your organization — and especially your marketing department — isn’t weighed down by software that doesn’t serve its purpose.

Understanding the Shelfware Issue

The concept of shelfware might seem relatively straightforward—a purchased software tool that gathers digital dust rather than delivering value. However, to truly address and combat this issue, one must understand its intricacies, historical context, and specific challenges, especially from a marketing perspective.

  1. Historical Perspective:
    • The term ‘shelfware’ harks back to a time when software was physically purchased, often on CDs, and if left unused, would literally sit on a shelf collecting dust. The digital transformation and the proliferation of SaaS (Software as a Service) platforms brought an evolution to this concept. Now, in a cloud-centric world, shelfware often manifests as recurring subscription fees for unused digital services, making it harder to detect but easier to accumulate.
  2. The Cost of Unused Software:
    • Financially, the implications are clear: wasted resources. Gartner’s estimation suggests that for an average company, 25% of software remains unused or underused. Translated to marketing, this means less budget for campaigns, market research, or other growth-driving initiatives.
  3. The Marketing Perspective:
    • From a marketer’s viewpoint, shelfware isn’t just an IT problem; it’s a barrier to optimal performance. Every unused tool represents potential insights not gained, campaigns not optimized, and audience segments not reached. Moreover, fragmented software usage can lead to fragmented data, impacting targeting, segmentation, and overall campaign ROI.
  4. Beyond Finances – The Hidden Dangers:
    • The costs aren’t just monetary. Shelfware poses tangible security risks. Unused or poorly managed software becomes a prime target for cyberattacks, especially if they’re not regularly updated or patched. Additionally, compliance becomes a concern. Partially implemented software, especially those dealing with customer data, might not adhere to regulatory standards, making companies vulnerable to legal repercussions.
  5. The Ease and Pitfalls of Modern Procurement:
    • The SaaS revolution has democratized software procurement. Departments, and even individual employees, can now easily purchase new tools without the traditional IT oversight. While this has accelerated digital adoption, it has also led to an environment where long-term contracts are often agreed upon without a holistic view of the company’s needs. As businesses evolve, many find themselves tethered to tools that no longer align with their strategies or objectives.
  6. The Ever-Changing Business Landscape:
    • Companies are organic entities, continuously evolving in response to market dynamics, regulatory changes, and internal shifts. Such changes can render previously essential tools redundant. Whether it’s an unexpected pivot in marketing strategy, regulatory changes affecting data handling, or organizational restructuring, the tools that were once deemed crucial can quickly become obsolete.

Understanding the multi-faceted nature of the shelfware issue is the first step in addressing it. It’s not just about identifying unused tools; it’s about fostering an environment where software procurement and management align closely with organizational needs, especially in realms like marketing where agility and data-driven decision-making are paramount.

Reimagining the Software Procurement and Management Process

Addressing shelfware isn’t simply a matter of cutting costs; it’s about revamping the entire approach to software procurement and management. The goal? To ensure that every tool purchased aligns with current and foreseeable organizational needs, offers tangible value, and remains relevant as the business landscape evolves.

  1. Centralized Oversight with Decentralized Procurement:
    • Centralizing software procurement doesn’t mean reverting to slow, bureaucratic processes. Instead, it’s about creating a centralized system where all software purchases are logged, tracked, and regularly reviewed. This allows departments or teams the freedom to choose tools that suit their needs while ensuring there’s oversight and a record of all subscriptions and licenses.
  2. Embracing Usage-Based Pricing Models:
    • One solution to the shelfware problem lies in the pricing model itself. Instead of traditional licensing, organizations should gravitate towards usage-based pricing where possible. This ensures that companies only pay for the software they actually use, offering scalability and flexibility in line with changing needs.
  3. Continuous Training and Onboarding:
    • The success of any software tool is directly tied to its adoption rate. Regular training sessions ensure that all team members, especially in dynamic departments like marketing, are well-acquainted with the tools in their stack. This maximizes adoption, ensures better ROI, and minimizes the chances of shelfware.
  4. Regular Software Audits and Reviews:
    • Instituting periodic software audits can help identify redundant tools or those that have fallen out of use. This should be complemented with feedback from end-users to understand any challenges they face or reasons they might have abandoned a particular tool.
  5. Flexible Contracts and Vendor Relationships:
    • Building strong relationships with software vendors can lead to more flexible contract terms. Whether it’s the ability to scale subscriptions based on current needs, or clauses that allow for adjustments in case of significant business changes, such flexibility can help in minimizing shelfware.
  6. Integration and Compatibility Checks:
    • Before any software purchase, it’s crucial to ensure that the new tool can seamlessly integrate with the existing tech stack. This prevents scenarios where a newly procured tool remains unused due to compatibility issues or the high costs of integration.
  7. Future-Proofing and Scalability:
    • The tools purchased should not just meet the current requirements but should also align with the company’s future vision. Scalable solutions that can grow with the organization and adapt to changing needs are less likely to become shelfware.
  8. Feedback Loops and Continuous Improvement:
    • Establishing feedback loops with end-users helps in understanding the efficacy of the tools in use. This continuous feedback aids in making informed decisions during subsequent software procurements, ensuring that the chosen solutions align closely with user needs and preferences.

By reimagining the software procurement and management process, organizations can ensure that their tech stack remains lean, efficient, and closely aligned with their operational needs. Especially in domains like marketing, where the right tool can make all the difference, this proactive approach ensures that investments in software drive tangible results rather than accumulate as shelfware.

Recommendations and Best Practices

Tackling the shelfware conundrum requires more than just understanding its nuances. It demands a proactive approach, rooted in best practices that can guide organizations in making the most of their software investments. Here are some recommendations tailored to help companies, especially marketing departments, mitigate the risk of shelfware:

  1. Conduct Regular Software Health Checks:
    • Beyond formal audits, cultivate a habit of conducting periodic health checks on your software tools. This involves analyzing usage patterns, checking for redundancies, and identifying any tools that are underutilized or have become obsolete.
  2. Cultivate a Culture of Open Communication:
    • Encourage teams, especially those in dynamic realms like marketing, to communicate their software needs, challenges, and feedback. An open channel of communication ensures that software purchases are in line with actual requirements and that any issues with existing tools are addressed promptly.
  3. Invest in SaaS Management Platforms:
    • Platforms like Quolum can provide insights into software usage, helping in identifying potential shelfware. Such tools can be invaluable in tracking software investments, analyzing usage patterns, and ensuring compliance.
  4. Prioritize Vendor Demos and Trials:
    • Before committing to a long-term contract or subscription, always opt for product demos and trial periods. This allows teams to test the tool’s fit for their specific needs, ensuring that the software aligns with their requirements and workflow.
  5. Establish Clear Software Procurement Protocols:
    • Implement clear guidelines for software procurement, which might include mandatory IT consultations, budget checks, and compatibility assessments. Such protocols can prevent impulsive purchases and ensure that every software addition is strategic.
  6. Embrace a Phased Implementation Approach:
    • Instead of rolling out new software to the entire organization simultaneously, adopt a phased approach. Start with a pilot group, gather feedback, address any issues, and then expand the rollout. This ensures smoother adoption and better alignment with user needs.
  7. Plan for Change Management:
    • Any new software tool, especially in realms like marketing, can introduce significant changes to workflows. Prepare for this by planning robust change management strategies, which include training sessions, documentation, and ongoing support.
  8. Review Contract Terms and Exit Clauses:
    • Always be clear on the terms of software contracts, especially regarding renewals, exit clauses, and any penalties associated with early termination or scaling down. This ensures that you’re not locked into tools that no longer serve your needs.
  9. Stay Updated on Market Trends:
    • The software landscape, especially for marketing tools, is ever-evolving. Stay updated on market trends, emerging tools, and best practices. This ensures that your tech stack remains current and that you’re not tied to outdated solutions.
  10. Seek Feedback from End-Users:
    • The true test of any software tool lies in its day-to-day usage. Regularly seek feedback from end-users, be it through surveys, feedback sessions, or informal chats. This helps in identifying any gaps, challenges, or areas of improvement.

By integrating these best practices into their software procurement and management strategies, organizations can not only prevent the accumulation of shelfware but also ensure that their tech stack remains agile, efficient, and aligned with their evolving needs.

Navigating the Shelfware Maze with Foresight and Strategy

The shelfware dilemma, at its core, isn’t just about unused software licenses or overlooked SaaS subscriptions. It’s a reflection of how rapidly evolving digital landscapes challenge businesses to constantly reassess their tools and strategies. It’s a reminder that in the race to stay ahead, it’s equally important to periodically look back and evaluate the tools we’ve accumulated along the way.

For marketers, this dilemma offers a unique opportunity. An opportunity to not only streamline their tech stack and save costs but to also harness the potential of every tool in their arsenal, ensuring maximum ROI. By recognizing the causes of shelfware and implementing the best practices discussed, organizations can transform this challenge into a strategic advantage.

In the end, the goal isn’t just to avoid shelfware, but to cultivate a proactive, agile approach to software management—one that continuously aligns with evolving business needs and maximizes value from every digital investment.

Leave a Comment